product design development stage-gate process

How to Avoid Costly Mistakes in Product Development

Navigating the intricate landscape of product development for HVAC electronic controls demands a strategic approach that not only ensures efficient manufacturing but also minimizes costly mistakes. With a myriad of project management methodologies available, choosing the right one is paramount. Depending on factors such as project complexity, regulatory adherence, team dynamics, and client requisites, selecting an approach that aligns with your organizational preferences is pivotal. In this context, the stage-gate process emerges as a standout choice, offering a comprehensive framework to mitigate risks and circumvent the financial pitfalls that can plague the development of HVAC electronic controls. To truly safeguard against these pitfalls, it’s essential to integrate a set of prudent practices aimed at avoiding costly errors during the product development journey.


Why Stage-Gate Process?


The gated project management process provides an opportunity to review and assess project performance, validate assumptions, evaluate risks, make decisions and adjust plans before committing to further resources to subsequent stages. The process helps enhance project control, manage uncertainties, and improve the likelihood of successful project outcomes.


Start with a Comprehensive Design Phase


Before moving into manufacturing, invest sufficient time and resources in a thorough design phase. By doing this, you mitigate the potential risks arising from subsequent changes in the later stages of the process. Clearly define the product requirements, specifications, and functionalities. Involve both the design and manufacturing teams early on to ensure that design choices align with manufacturability or meet the standards of DFx (Design for Excellence). Choosing a partner that provides both design and manufacturing full service creates a more seamless experience. Use simulation tools where possible to limit issues and risks at later stages. Address potential challenges, trade-offs and review component choices and alternate sources during this phase to avoid costly revisions later.  


Collaborate and Communicate Effectively


Establish clear lines of communication between the design and manufacturing teams. Regularly scheduled meetings and open channels of communication ensure that any design-related concerns, potential manufacturing challenges, or design changes are promptly addressed. Encourage collaborative problem-solving to prevent misunderstandings and reduce the risk of errors.  Again, another reason to choose a partner that provides and is responsible for both design and manufacturing.


Prototype and Test Iteratively


Develop prototypes and conduct rigorous testing at various stages of development. This iterative approach helps identify design flaws, functional issues and manufacturing challenges early in the process. Catching problems in the prototype phase is more cost-effective than addressing them after mass production has begun.


Involve Manufacturing and Supply Chain Early


Engage the manufacturing team from the outset of the product development process. Their insights into material availability, assembly techniques, and production processes are invaluable. Their expertise can guide the design decisions to ensure that the product is manufacturable within budget and time constraints.


Prioritize Quality Assurance and Testing


Implement a robust quality assurance (QA) and testing process. Rigorous testing helps uncover defects, performance issues and potential reliability problems before the product reaches the market. Design and manufacturing teams should collaborate closely on test plans to ensure all aspects of the product are thoroughly evaluated.


Identifying Issues throughout the Product Development Process


Avnan’s process involves 3 key product development phases before mass production. The goal is to identify and fix any design related issues before mass production while creating a stable production environment thereby avoiding any issues that could result in a product recall.


During the engineering verification testing (EVT) phase, a prototype is produced as a proof of concept to test the functionality and design at first pass.  It’s important to troubleshoot as many bugs as possible to get it as close as possible to the intended design concept with minimal functional issues. Tasks include simulation, pre-scanning, evaluation of required tooling for the DVT phase, all designed to identify and fix issues that could impact time and money later. In theory, if done correctly, this should be the longest phase in the development cycle


In the design validation testing (DVT) phase, the team has the opportunity to make the necessary adjustments to improve the design. They implement a product qualification process to the maximum detail and ensure that the product works through UL/CSA testing while meeting the regulatory and compliance requirements. In this phase, they will also test the tooled parts using the DVT cycle validation tests. Any failure in design at this stage could result in a flawed product that would also be costly and time consuming. 


In the production validation testing (PVT) phase, the team completes the working design and the product is sent to manufacturing to produce a pilot batch using the official manufacturing tools and process. This provides the team with an opportunity to iron out all the product details and specifications while testing the manufacturing process before mass production. Any failures or deficiencies not addressed, like improper tooling not adjusted, will result in manufacturing issues. In theory, at this stage of development, the product is acceptable for market consumption.


Seamless Collaboration


The success of product development of electronic controls hinges on a seamless collaboration and having the right checks and balances along the production journey. Implementing a progressive stage-gate process fortifies against costly mistakes in time and money. This, coupled with comprehensive design, effective collaboration, iterative testing, early manufacturing involvement and unwavering quality assurance forms the foundations of success. 


Avnan’s three-step process emphasizes precluding errors before mass production. From EVT to PVT, there are opportunities to identify and adjust for the potential issues that can result in costly mistakes. In navigating product development of HVAC controls, OEMs must embrace proactive strategies – precise design, rigorous testing and robust communication. All of these safeguard against errors and steers toward an innovative, reliable product in the HVAC realm.

Tell Us About Your Project

Read More

Related Posts